| |
Home Latest News Homeless & Destitute PHRAA, Park Home Residents Action Alliance | Wednesday, 19 November 2008 |
|
|
|
Newsflash |
The Park Home Residents Action Alliance (PHRAA) a voluntary National Park Home Association working exclusively for the right of Park Homeowners towards a FAIR DEAL is launching this Petition to give ALL Park Homeowners the opportunity to take an active part in obtaining a secure future free of explotation.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Statistics |
|
Visitors: 70173
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
Written by Ron Joyce
|
|
Sunday, 13 January 2008 |
|
PARK HOME RESIDENTS ACTION ALLIANCE
PHRAA
Homeless & Destitute
A disturbing factual report to Government setting out the plight of helpless Park Homeowners losing their homes and life savings after buying a Park Home.
PARK HOMEOWNERS MADE HOMELESS DESTITUTE AND BANKRUPT. THE HIDDEN SCANDAL OF THE PARK HOMES INDUSTRY.
“SELL UP YOUR BRICKS AND MORTAR HOME, INVEST THE RELEASED CAPITAL IN BUYING A PARK HOME, WHERE YOU WILL BE GUARANTEED TO ENJOY YOUR RETIREMENT YEARS IN THE SAFE, TROUBLE FREE AND BLISSFULLY PEACEFULL ENVIRONMENT OF THE PARK HOME LIFESTYLE, LEAVING YOU WITH SURPLUS MONEY TO SPARE YOU CAN USE TO TAKE THOSE EXOTIC HOLIDAYS AND SPEND ON THOSE EXTRA LUXURIES OF LIFE YOU HAVE ALWAYS DREAMED OF, BUT COULD NEVER AFFORD”.
This is a typical example of the ecstatic vision of Park Home life as portrayed by the hundreds of pages of glowing advertising and feature articles screaming out from the pages of specialist Park Home Magazines, the press and the media, all extolling the virtues in their efforts to persuade those approaching their Autumn years that the park home lifestyle would be the ideal way to spend their retirement years, but carefully omitting any mention of the fact that what they will be actually buying is officially classed as a CARAVAN stationed on a CARAVAN SITE and they will now be classed as CARAVAN DWELLERS. Neither is any mention made of any of the other numerous hidden, expensive and potentially dangerous pitfalls plus the fact that there is no adequate provision in law to protect the unsuspecting Park Home buyers from exploitation. The old adage that “if it looks too be to good to be true then it probably is“ For all too many who have succumbed to the advertising have found to their cost, the adage is right, “it is too good to be true.”
Behind the glossy façade presented by the park home industry vulnerable and unprotected by the law, 70, 80 and 90 year old Park Homeowners are being robbed of their homes and assets totaling Millions of Pounds by greedy and unscrupulous Park Home Site Owners.
50 distraught elderly Park Homeowners face eviction from their own homes and a combined loss of over £3,000,000 life savings on one site in the Midlands. (Based on a very conservative estimate of £60,000 per home) 13 homeowners on a park in the North of England have recently been forced to abandon their homes to the park owner for the paltry sum of £2,000 each resulting in an estimated combined loss of £530,000. The 2 remaining homeowners are desperately fighting on, but face the loss of their homes valued at £135,000 and £80,000 respectively because their park is subject to a limited lease agreement. 20 homeowners on a park in the South of England have recently been evicted from their own homes, combined losses of over £1,000,000 due to a limited lease agreement.
Due to the activities of just one multiple park owner alone, (exposed in recent BBC Inside Out and Radio 4 Face the Facts programmes) who by using the relevant clause in the MOBILE HOMES ACT 1983/2006, prevents homeowners from selling their homes, 30 homeowners on a park in Shropshire face losing their homes with combined losses of over £2,000,000. 30 more in Wolverhampton £2,000,000. 21 in South Staffordshire well over £1,500,000. Another unknown number in Shropshire have already been driven from their homes by this same park owner resulting in a loss of their homes and a further £1,000,000 plus. The homeowners on a park in Wales containing 100 homes all own homes which are virtually worthless with a potential combined loss exceeding £6,000,000 Multiply the few examples above by the estimated 250,000 park homeowners, who have paid between £100,000 - £300,000 each for their homes, throughout the whole of the country, none of which can sell their homes without the permission of the park owner, and the total amount of potential loss, in homeowners assets alone, reaches astronomical proportions.
Every year hundreds of pensioners, many very elderly and frail, are losing both their park homes and the equity tied up in those homes. In addition to those being prevented by the park owner from selling their homes, many others are being subjected to an unbearable intensive programme of bullying, threats and harassment causing them to become so terrified of their unscrupulous park owner they abandon their Park Homes. This usually follows the sale of their park to a new park owner determined to clear all existing homes off the park in order to replace existing homes with new. A massive profit for the Park Owner. Homelessness and destitution for the displaced devastated homeowners. This widespread practice alone, recently exposed in several BBC Inside Out, Watchdog and Radio 4 Face the Facts prgrammes, results in collectively millions of pounds of pensioners life savings going straight into Park Owners pockets.
The above examples are not isolated cases produced to sensationalise or exaggerate. These are factual, truthful, everyday examples of the outrageous abuse and exploitation of elderly 60,70,80 and 90 year old Park Homeowners left helpless and totally defenseless against the despicable activities, (which in every other section of society except the park Home Industry would be held to be criminal actions) against them by unscrupulous park owners.
The fact that unscrupulous park owners, usually aided by their “clever” legal advisors and trade organisations, are able to continue and escalate this outrageous exploitation of Park Homeowners with virtual immunity from sanction from the law is due entirely to the lack of any enforceable legislation to protect the homeowner other than the loophole ridden Mobile Homes Act 1983/2006., which places the entire responsibility for its enforcement solely on the shoulders of the elderly and vulnerable Park Homeowner. This effectively leaves the devastated homeowners in the untenable position of being held to ransom by the park owner. The only form of redress available to the already terrified homeowner is to undertake very risky, long, traumatic and very expensive legal action against the park owner, which could take months or even years to get to court. This course of action depends entirely on whether…. (1)… The homeowner has sufficient funds to pay Solicitors bills and court costs. (2) … Is able to find a Solicitor with sufficient knowledge of Mobile Home Law, which, due to the ambiguity of the Mobile Homes Act, is virtually impossible. (3)…. Due to his age is physically or mentally is he in a fit state to endure such a lengthy and traumatic undertaking.
Taking Court Action against a Park Owner for the Homeowner is a course of action fraught with danger. The park homeowner has very limited funds and probably engages a local solicitor with a very scant knowledge of park home law. Against him is the park owner who has ample funds to employ the services of specialist legal firms who are experts at exploiting every loophole in the Mobile homes Act to their own and the park owners advantage. However if the homeowner has sufficient funds and has been able to obtain a solicitor fully conversant with park home law and decides to proceed with an action against the park owner he then faces a new problem when the case does eventually reach Court. The legal definition of Park/Mobile Homes (as explained elsewhere in this report) is a CARAVAN, stationed on a CARAVAN SITE.. Park/Mobile Homes are not officially classed as Housing and excluded from the Housing Act. Unfortunately for the homeowner much of the Legal Profession, including many Solicitors, Barristers and Judges, have little or no understanding of the Park Home Lifestyle and follow the legal definition regarding Park/Mobile Homeowners as CARAVAN DWELLERS who travel from place to place. This results in actions brought before the Court by park homeowners being lost.
Given these facts the park homeowner has very little chance of obtaining justice and can, if unsuccessful be faced with paying not only his own costs, but also those of the park owner which will be substantial and will result in the devastated homeowner losing his home, his life savings, and as in one case recently in the South of England actually being made Bankrupt by his vindictive park owner at 80 years of age. (To verify Telephone Francis Triplow 01462 624728) Another an elderly Widow lost her home just to mention two. As an example of the length of time it takes for a homeowner to obtain a Court Hearing, two elderly widows on a park in Wolverhampton, both of whom have been forced by ill health and continual harassment from their park owner, to move into alternative sheltered and warden controlled accommodation respectively.
Both homes professionally valued by a national firm of estate agents at approximately £90,000 each. Each of these homes, which have attracted several willing purchasers have, because the park owner has stopped the sale on every occasion by his illegal actions, remained unsold and unoccupied for over two years. Both Widows instigated separate legal proceedings against the park owner some two years ago and to date their cases still has to reach a Court Hearing. Is it any wonder that given the examples above that unscrupulous park owners, aided by the Mobile Homes Act are able to totally ignore the law and homeowners cave in under the pressure and sell their homes back to the park owner for a pittance. £500 - £2,000 are typical examples of prices paid to helpless park homeowners for homes professionally valued at £50,000 - £100,000 plus and had attracted willing buyers every one of which had been stopped from buying by the actions of the park owner. EVERY ONE OF THE ESTIMATED 250,000 PARK HOMEOWNERS IN THE UK ARE POTENTIAL VICTIMS OF THIS OUTRAGEOUS AND WIDELY USED PRACTICE. Whether they have paid a few thousand pounds for a second hand older home or up to £300,000 for a brand new one, it makes no difference. From the moment the purchase of a park home is completed, potentially that home is only worth what the park owner is prepared to pay for it. Because the home is stationed on the park owners land, and as a direct result of the Act, the homeowner is trapped. The only two means of escape available to a homeowner in this position is to accept a pittance for his home losing everything, or be taken out in a wooden box.
But even in death the homeowner cannot escape from the clutches of the all powerful park owner. The Act also gives the park owner control of who is entitled to inherit the late homeowners home. The beneficiary who the Act dictates must be a member of the late homeowners family cannot move in without the permission of the park owner, neither can they sell the home without the park owners permission. Thus everyday many more homes are being abandoned to unscrupulous park owners and beneficiaries being deprived of their inheritance.
Purchasing a Park Home is very different to purchasing bricks and mortar. Except for Council Tax purposes Park or Mobile Homes as they are officially known are classed as CARAVANS not Housing, but CHATTEL, stationed on CARAVAN SITES. Park Homes are purchased in exactly the same way as any other chattel such as a car or TV. No Solicitor is required, in fact many park owners actively discourage prospective buyers from employing the use of solicitors to oversee the transaction.
The right of the owner of a Park/Mobile Home to station the home on the Park owners land is subject to a unique form of contract known as the “WRITTEN STATEMENT” UNDER THE MOBILE HOMES ACT 1983/2006, (the Act governing Park/Mobile Homes) entered into by the purchaser at the time of purchase. This Act appears on paper to afford some degree of protection to owners of Park Homes regarding security of tenure and other rights, But in practice the Act and the contract are so ambiguous and riddled with loopholes, together with the total lack of any powers of enforcement, it effectively places the absolute power in the hands of the Park Owner, especially the UNSCRUPULOUS PARK OWNERS, to rule every aspect of the lives of the unfortunate Park Homeowners with virtual impunity.
There are four main methods open to Park Owners under the present Mobile Homes Act which are being widely used everyday nationwide to rob Park Homeowners of their homes and the tens and hundreds of thousands of pounds in equity each Park Homeowner has invested in their homes.
(1)….. The right given to the Park Owner by the Act to interfere with the Park Homeowners right to sell their home and assign the contract to the new occupier.
(2)…… The existence or creation of type of Lease arrangement whereby the Park owners interest in the Land (Park) is of limited duration.
(3)…… The Park Owner decides that all existing homes are to be removed from the Park to enable complete redevelopment.
(4)….. The right of the park owner to a 10% commission payment on the sale price of the home, payable by the outgoing homeowner.
Before proceeding to elaborate upon the 4 bullet points listed above, we would again ask the reader to bear in mind the average age and vulnerability of the typical Park Homeowner, which ranges from 55 years, being usually the minimum age accepted by the park owner, to 90 plus years. They will have sold their bricks and mortar homes having been led to believe that the Park Home lifestyle will be more suitable for their needs during their remaining years and fully expecting that, either at the end of their lives they will have an appreciating asset to pass on to their loved ones, or should their health fail, or they wish to move nearer to their family etc., they will be able to sell their park home and use the released capital to take care of their future welfare. Unfortunately for all too many of these aged, innocent and extremely vulnerable park homeowners, when this time comes, because of the abuse of the power given to the park owner by the ACT, they are devastated to find that they are prevented from selling except to the park owner for a pittance.
(1)….. Park Owners right of approval of incoming homeowners.
Section 8 Paragraph (1) of the Implied Terms of the Mobile Homes Act 1983/2006 states that “The occupier (Homeowner) shall be entitled to sell the mobile home, and to assign the agreement (contract), to a person approved of by the owner, whose approval shall not be unreasonably withheld.”
This clause in the Act, which states that the homeowner can only sell his home to a person approved of by the park owner is, by far, the major cause of financial loss to the park homeowner, and has the potential to effect every one of the estimated 250,000 park homeowners in the country. It is widely exploited by unscrupulous park owners as a virtually foolproof method of successfully preventing the helpless homeowner from selling their homes on the open market for the true market value thus depriving the helpless home owner of Hundreds of Thousands of Pounds of the capital invested in that home needed to sustain them in their future life.
Every day without fail PHRAA receives a call from a distressed 70, 80 or 90 year old park homeowner pleading for help because the park owner will not allow him to sell his park home. The park owner takes the opportunity presented to him by using this right of approval to put off, using various dubious methods, every prospective buyer until such time as the helpless homeowner, who may through failing health had to enter sheltered, or other more suitable accommodation, leaving the home standing empty for many months awaiting sale also now in the impossible situation of having to pay for the upkeep of two properties, becomes so desperate that he is left with no other option, but to accept the derisory offer from the park owner.
The only form of redress available to the homeowner being prevented from selling his home on the open market is to undertake very risky Legal Action against the Park Owner. This is a very daunting exercise for a young fit and able person with ample funds to employ legal representation, but is hardly likely to be a course of action undertaken by a frightened elderly pensioner with little or nothing in the way of financial resources. Added to which it can be months, even years, before the case is brought before the Court during which time many buyers will have been lost.
(2)….. Park Owners Interest in the land ends on……..
Normally a Park Home Site has planning permission for use as a Permanent Residential Park/Mobile Home Site. This means that the owners of Park Homes have security of tenure on that site for ever. But there are cases where the site, although having been granted Permanent Planning Permission by the Local Authority, the ownership of the land which forms the site, may be subject to a Leasing agreement of limited duration. Therefore homeowners only have security of tenure up until the date of expiry, after which all homes and their occupants have to leave the site immediately.
Unfortunately many homeowners may not have been made aware of the limited lease at the time they purchased their homes, or they may have received assurances from the park owner or advisers that it was not a problem as the lease would be continually renewed. (Rolling Lease) However it can be, as in the case referred to at the beginning of this article, that homeowners only become aware that the lease exists or will not be renewed, when they come to sell and find that not only is their home worthless, but they will be rendered homeless when the lease expires. To add further to their distress each homeowner may well be faced with a large bill from the park owner for the removal and disposal of the home from the park.
The creation of a lease arrangement is a foolproof method employed by park owners to override the security of tenure, as implied by the terms of the Mobile Homes Act normally enjoyed by the homeowners on a park with permanent planning permission for use as a park home site, as it ensures that when the expiry date of the lease is reached, all homes will be removed from the park, leaving the park owner free to clear the park and refill the vacant plots with new homes at no cost to himself, but depriving the displaced homeowners of their homes and the equity tied invested in those homes as the 20 homeowners on a park who have recently lost collectively well over £1,000,000 (a very conservative estimate) and their homes. The use of this method guarantees the park owner a huge income in profit from selling new homes on the same park every so many years.
(3)….. Development of existing Parks.
On glancing through any of the Park Home advertising material appearing in specialist magazines and the press one cannot fail to notice how many Parks have changed ownership and are now being advertised as undergoing new development with brand new homes being offered for sale. This means that the existing homes, including their occupiers have vacated the park in order for this development to take place. But has anybody in authority, and particularly those purchasing these brand new homes, ever consider what happened to the previous existing homeowners and what caused them to leave the park? Do they know, or even care, that in most cases the new park owner will have embarked on an intensive programme of intimidation, bullying, harassment, threats and abuse, all designed to make life for the unfortunate homeowners so unbearable that one by one they are driven to abandon their homes, receiving, if they are lucky, a few hundred pounds for their home, thus clearing the way for his new homes. This is well documented fact as recent excellent BBC Inside Out, Watchdog and Radio 4 Face the Facts programmes have revealed. Hundreds of elderly vulnerable park homeowners have collectively already lost millions of pounds of their money and more and more are suffering the same fate every day.
(4)…. The right of the park owner to a 10% Commission payment on the sale price of the home, payable by the outgoing homeowner.
Each and every time a park home is sold by its owner the Act states that the park owner shall receive a payment from the seller of up to 10% of the price received from the buyer.
This clause in the Act is the one of the most despised by homeowners, many of whom do not even know of its existence until such time as they come to sell. Recent calls upon Government by homeowners and their representatives, including PHRAA, to reduce the rate to 7.5% were rejected in favour of the industries wish to retain the status quo. Whether a homeowner has sold his home of his own free will, been forced to sell by declining health reasons, been forced to take Court Action to obtain the park owners approval for his buyer, or been driven out by the illegal actions of an unscrupulous park owner, the 10% is still payable. This outrageous charge, unique to the park home industry, on any person selling his own personal property (chattel) can only be regarded as the last kick in the teeth inflicted, with the backing of the law, by the park owner, on one of the most vulnerable and widely abused, members of society, the helpless park homeowner and must be abolished forthwith.
The main purpose of this PHRAA report is to bring to the Governments attention, the incalculable financial losses suffered by 60,70 80 and 90 year old park homeowners. But it is also vitally important to emphasise the deep despair and feeling of complete desolation, suffered by the helpless park homeowners faced with losing their homes and every penny of the life savings tied up in their homes. Having endured months, even years of stress, harassment and intimidation their health deteriorates. Doctors Surgeries are full of Park Homeowner patients suffering stress related illnesses and being treated with tranquilisers all brought on by the despicable actions of a park owner intent on getting them off his park. Does anyone in Government give any thought whatsoever to the devastating effect on an aged person of being forced, not only from your own home, but also robbed of the life savings tied up in that home on which the helpless elderly homeowner had relied on to support them for the few short years remaining to them on this earth? If being made homeless and destitute at a great age was not bad enough, They will have also been torn from their community, away from their friends, having to adapt to a totally new way of life in a strange area and being forced, possibly for the first time in their lives, to depend upon state benefits to survive. It is also very likely that as park homes contain built in furniture, which cannot be removed, new furniture, even a bed may have to be purchased.
Those who are capable try desperately to stand firm and fight for their homes, but soon find that their pleas for help have been rejected by every one in authority, including local authorities, the Police, Trading Standards officers, even solicitors, all of which are powerless to help. It is then they find to their horror that there is no protection whatsoever available for the park homeowner against the uncontrolled and ruthless activities of the ever increasing number of ruthless unscrupulous park owners, who with the aid of their very clever Legal Advisors, are experts at exploiting and turning to their full advantage, every one of the gaping loopholes, contained within the terms of the ambiguous, outdated, unenforceable, (from the homeowners point of view) Mobile Homes Act 1983. This Act, the terms of which give the park owner powers on a par with those granted to the landowners in medieval times, when the local Baron had absolute control over his helpless subjects and forelock tugging was the normal way of life gives the park owner, because he owns the land upon which the homeowners home stands, virtually total control over the lives of park homeowners..
The Amendments to the Act that came into force in 2006 which the Government assured homeowners would curb the power of the unscrupulous park owner, have in most cases made the plight of homeowners far worse than before. Park Owners, their trade organisations and legal advisors have seized the opportunity to insert new restrictive clauses in the agreements (contracts) tightening the noose around the innocent park homeowner even further. Even the democratic right of wives and partners to a vote on matters affecting their life on the park has been abolished by this new legislation. Severe restrictions have been imposed on the homeowners right to sell homes over ten years old.
It is an indisputable fact that in this country in 2007 where Park Homeowners are concerned two different sets of laws exist. One set applies to the general public and the other unique set known as “The Mobile Homes Act 1983/2006” or as in its present form would be more accurately described as “The Unscrupulous Park Owners Absolute Right to Abuse and Exploit His Residents Act” which, as any park home owner finds to his cost the first time he encounters problems with his park owner, effectively overrides most of the laws he relied on and took for granted before he moved on to a park home site. As already mentioned all the usual agencies such as the Police, Local Authorities etc., even Trading Standards and Solicitors, normally relied upon for assistance by every other citizen not residing in park homes, are prevented from taking action against the park owner by this Act. The only law that applies to a park homeowner is that dictated by the park owner. Is it any wonder that the most common phrase used by disillusioned and desperate park homeowners to describe the park home lifestyle is that “WE ARE SECOND CLASS CITIZENS LIVING IN PRISON CAMPS FOR PENSIONERS”?
ACTION IS URGENTLY NEEDED NOW TO END THE EXPLOITATION OF PARK HOMEOWNERS ALLOWED AND ESCALATING UNCONTROLLED BY THIS OUTDATED AND DISCREDITED MOBILE HOMES ACT, WHICH FAVOURS THE ASPIRATIONS OF THE PARK OWNER OVER AND ABOVE THE WELFARE OF THE HOMEOWNER. THE LONGER ACTION TO CURB THE POWER OF PARK OWNERS IS DELAYED, THE MORE PARK HOMEOWNERS WILL CONTINUE TO SUFFER LOSING THEIR HOMES AND LIFE SAVINGS.
Park Home manufactures, Park Owners, Park Home Industries Trade Organisations and the Government are all actively engaged in promoting the Park Home as an alternative form of housing which is making a valuable contribution to help ease the current national housing shortage. Why then does the Government not recognise Park Homes as Housing instead of the present classification as CARAVANS stationed on CARAVAN SITES? It is surely outrageous in the 21st century that a persons permanent home costing up to £300,000, permanently stationed on a plot of land is classed as a “CARAVAN”. (defined as any moveable structure except a tent, constructed or adapted for human habitation, capable of being moved from place to place) Equally outrageous is the fact that a park home is “chattel”.
Although PHRAA fully supports promoting the important role that park homes contribute to the housing crisis, but not at the expense of the welfare of the elderly and most vulnerable members of society who are mainly the ones that favour the park home lifestyle. Abuse of the elderly is rife throughout the park home industry. Supported by the Mobile Homes Act, “clever legal teams and their trade associations, more and more Unscrupulous Park Owners are becoming multi- millionaires by making obecene profits from exploiting the thousands of helpless homeowners losing their homes and life savings.
It is said that “an Englishmans home is his castle”. Not for park homeowners while this archaic Mobile Homes Act, which has no place in the 21st Century, remains unchanged.
Further information available on PHRAA Website www.phraa.co.uk.
Or Telephone Ron Joyce on 01902 373462.
Compiled and produced for PHRAA by Ron Joyce. General Secretary.
November 2007
|
|
Last Updated ( Sunday, 13 January 2008 )
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
| |
 |
|
© 2008 PHRAA, Park Home Residents Action Alliance
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.
Design & Hosting by D3 Developments | D3 Developments Web Directory
|